I’ve got two confessions to make: 1. This will be one of my
longest reviews (so prepare for some lengthy read), and 2. I was overflowing
with ideas when I started writing, which is why I had a very hard time making
up my mind with regards to the composition.
Yes, that’s right, I had thought of quite a few angles to
start the review with, only to have spent a lot of time and energy mulling over
the one I want to develop. For instance, I wanted to start with a detailed
postmortem on why I’m so disappointed with her previous effort, but then I
thought that would’ve been redundant. I also thought of venting my distaste on
why every Bossa Nova albums need to have The Girl from Ipanema, a proclivity
I’ve grown sick of. (Side note: I could swear that song gets included or
covered in more albums than New Zealand’s population.)
But then, this album didn’t have that track, much to my
applause.
A week ago, I went to an underground record store with my
friend and, guess what, we saw Elizabeth Ramsey (Jaya’s mom). I could care less
about meeting a celebrity, but instincts tell me that a conversation wouldn’t
be so bad. Besides, I’ve done some interviews in my college years, so I might
still be able to adroitly break the silence.
Most of the topics became quite forgettable and
prosaic– like the what’s-up’s and the how-are-you’s. However, there was one interesting topic I had raised. Since she told me she performs jazz, I
asked her why that particular genre couldn’t thrive in our native soils. This
is the paraphrase of her reply:
"The main problem is that the great jazz musicians of yore
didn’t pass the legacy to their offsprings. The only way Jazz will resurge is
if someone of the current generation promotes it."
What’s Mrs. Ramsey’s opinion of Sitti? I don’t have a clue
(and I didn’t ask). The first time I read about Sitti Navarro was after I heard
her first endeavor and before the Ramsey conversation. She’s a UP graduate –
and a pretty one at that – who aspires to bring forth a renaissance of Jazz and
Bossa Nova. My guess is that she has, like me, become absorbed to the lure of
those genres’ cultures and creativities. As a trivia, one among her favorite
artists is Ella Fitzgerald, and one among my favorite artists is Louis
Armstrong. When the two of them got together, the result was magical.
And what happened when I first heard Sitti’s music? Well,
the review is in my archives, but long story short: I held a very high
expectation, and I got thrown off by some of her decisions. The tracks were
forgetful and the percussions were unwieldy. I could go on.
So in its conclusion, I overtly admitted that if that’s the
kind of jazz that would be made popular, then count me out. Looking back, that
was a little harsh – and I’m sure that’s quite an understatement, because a guy
by the name of Patch posted comments objecting to my review. Needless to say,
there was a small chunk of Intarwebs drama that unfolded.
While my views about the previous album are uncompromising
(sorry guys), Patch told me Sitti performs way better on live; and I considered it.
Today, I bought the album, and I’m going to be among the first to review it,
whether in print or in e-media.
So, I ended up telling a long story. That’s the angle I
chose.
Now here’s another two confessions: I think my previous
review was inadequate from a musical standpoint, because: 1. Had you no idea of
who Sitti is, you wouldn’t know what Sitti’s voice sound like before and after
you read that review. 2. I failed to tell you that percussion was the prime
culprit of why I didn’t like the album.
Sitti Live is the recording of her concert in…where exactly?
I couldn’t find it in the liner notes. Please enlighten me.
Speaking of liner notes, it was, like the cover, awful. Now
I’m not the most finicky when it comes to designs, but this album’s packaging
reeks of lazy marketing. Other jazz albums (that I own) have designs that could easily be exhibited in museums. And their liner notes contains stories
that are a joy to read. This album’s, though, only had acknowledgments. It didn’t
even give any explicit mention as to who the composers of the tracks are. There
aren’t any lyrics, and it’s not as if Sitti’s pictures were taken at her best
angle. Just because it’s live doesn’t automatically make it okay to have bad packaging! (Look at Duke Ellington at Newport, Waltz for Debby, Sunday at Village Vanguard, etc.) What is it exactly that the record company didn’t understand about jazz industry? If they think these things don’t matter, they’re seriously breaking my
heart.
To prove my point, here are some samples from my collection:
—————————————————————————————




—————————————————————————————
Oh what the heck, I’m just going to let it slide. After all,
the cover isn’t everything (but still!) Remember what Patch said about Sitti’s
concerts? Since this album is a record of her doing live, it’s fair to raise
the burning question: is she better?
I said it before, but no doubt Sitti has talent. I’m now
going to add that I actually liked her voice. While she may not be able pull
off an alto very well – at least not like Norah Jones or Anita O’ Day – her
mezzo-soprano is plenty fine, and this is typically her vocal range, although
she sometimes also sings on falsetto. Aside from that, her vibrato is very
crisp, and sometimes very forceful. It actually enhances her songs (when
they’re actually good) by providing many emotions. If one should draw
comparisons, she sounds like a blend of Ella’s forceful voice and Astrud’s
honeydipped voice. It’s quite distinct, that you’d immediately recognize it
from miles away – the same way as with Nina Simone, Billie Holiday, etc.
But in the first album it’s either the percussions were
bogging down her voice, or that she was singing too much without leaving room
for the other instruments. It wouldn’t have mattered much in rock or hiphop,
but we’re talking about Bossa Nova or Jazz, which, as we all know, place
ALL instruments at high importance.
In Sitti Live, however, things are very different. I’d be
taking too much credit if I say that Sitti and her ensemble took my comment
into heart, but she really did improve. Right here, she shows to a greater
extent what she’s capable of, by sometimes using her voice as percussion
instead of the main melody. She also learned a few things on how to pause. They
do leave room for the instruments to improvise and rollick.
This is where I noticed that some among her band shows a
tremendous amount of skill, which again is not fleshed out previously. The guitarist, in
particular, sounds fantastic. He could develop into the next Wes Montgomery,
and that’s saying much.
There are many tracks in this album, and I would divide it
into four segments: One Note Samba-Fever, Para Sa Akin- I Didn’t Know I Was
Looking for Love, Waters of March – Lanca Perfume, and Pais Tropical – Mas Que
Nada. The first segment mostly deals with Bossa and Jazz standards, but the
rendition is loud. Some of the renditions, particularly Agua de Beber, reminds
me so much of Sonny Rollins’ Global Warming, also from his live album
(Without a Song). That’s a good thing. The second segment is mostly Bossa Nova version
of popular tracks. Frankly, it isn’t quite as well done as I would’ve liked
(that Tattooed in my Mind still sounds like RnB), but thankfully it’s
short-lived. The third segment follows the Bossa Nova format more closely. The
last segment builds up an upbeat, dramatic and lively finale, and the result works a lot
better than a Philippine traffic enforcer. Bad metaphors aside, I can say I liked the 1st, 3rd and 4th segment. They’re great.
So to answer Patch’s question: Yes, she’s better in live
performances. But while my praises have, so far, been gushing, there still are
a few flaws that I can’t overlook.
First, there’s the percussion. While the difference of the
last album to this one is that of near-nausea to near-euphoria, sometimes there
are crashes and booms at the most jarring times. I feel as though the drummer
is better off being on a rock band.
The rests are more nitpicky. There’s one instance in Fever where the bass,
typically a support instrument, got into the front line. Now the bassist is
good, and I was reaching a high state when, as if splashed by cold water, Sitti
said "Get a touch of the bass." Uh, yeah, he’s great. Scott LaFaro didn’t need
Bill Evans to tell the audience that the bass in Jade Vision is fantabulous.
Charles Mingus never said, "’Yo homey, pay attention! I’m the bassist and the leader of the
band!" It’s like me declaring "This is my best review yet". Leave it to the audience to decide, Sitti, we can listen plenty fine.
Lastly, people who expect this album to
be of the relaxing kind, prepare to be disappointed. If you find yourself falling asleep in listening to her songs from this album, you seriously need to diagnose for A.D.D. Most of tracks inside are
quite loud, definitely not the kind for lounging. I don’t see this as
a bad thing. (Dude, I have 5 John Coltrane albums!)
Yet, despite all those, there’s no denying that Sitti Live
is a huge improvement over the predecessor. And even when taken alone, it’s
still quite a solid outing. Is it perfect? No. Is it great nonetheless? Why,
yes. And at 290 pesos, you can’t go wrong especially since it’s one of the more
inexpensive jazz albums that aren’t junk. There’s a lot of personality. The
entire band indulges on improvisations, highlights on rollicking, and conduces
to swinging; and that’s what Jazz really is. Ok, so maybe some of her tracks sound more like Latin music, but isn’t that where (along with Jazz) Bossa traced its roots - please, do we need a lecture on this? The point is that she performed excellently. I’m glad Sitti got it right this
time. I’m now looking forward to more. Score: 4 out of 5.
So here’s to Mrs. Ramsey: Sitti might just be THAT person.
Track picks: Agua de Beber, Pais Tropical, and Mas Que Nada.
Wish list: Hire a pianist. Cover some non-bossa, Jazz standards, like Body and Soul, Work Song, They Can’t Take That Away From Me, I Got My Love To Keep Me Warm, Autum In New York, etc.
(Unrelated: By the way, if you ever want to buy great Jazz
CD’s, don’t go to Fullybooked Greenhills; because chances are, I’ve already
bought it.
They have two copies of John Coltrane’s Love Supreme:
Deluxe Edition though. Seeing as how I already own one, I won’t be buying
another, so feel free to spend your money away. It’s P600, but I can say it’s
absolutely worth it especially if you’re into hard bop jazz. And the packaging
is great, too. I’d give it a perfect rating. Heck, why even bother listening to me? It’s shortlisted in Time Magazine’s "Top 7 Best Jazz Album of All Time"
By the way, it would really help if someone can find me a copy of John Coltrane’s "Giant Steps".)